Browse Source

add kalkhoff draft article

master
Schoenberger, Philipp 6 years ago
parent
commit
bf7e860190
  1. 102
      content/blog/05_durban_display_en.md
  2. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/Kh17_PRO_DURBAN-g9.jpg
  3. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/TN-GSD-G1-touring.jpg
  4. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/bafang_motor.jpg
  5. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_bms.jpg
  6. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_cells.jpg
  7. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_connector.jpg
  8. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_side.jpg
  9. BIN
      content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_loaded.jpg

102
content/blog/05_durban_display_en.md

@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
title: Kalkhoff durban G9 Ebike - Display mod
date: 2019-08-25
author: Philipp Schönberger
tags: bicycle, ebike, display, bafang, durban g9, kalkhoff
category: projects
E-bike buying decision
----------------------
Last year in October I bought a Kalkhoff durban G9. It is a 28" bike with a mix between a
load bicycle and a touring bicycle.
[lightgallery
/images/blog/TN-GSD-G1-touring.jpg Tern GSD Source: https://www.ternbicycles.com
/images/blog/Kh17_PRO_DURBAN-g9.jpg Kalkhoff Durban G9 Source: https://www.derby-cycle.com
lightgalleryend]
It wasn't my first choice but for my usage it is enough and fulfilled all requirements.
I wanted to have a normal size bicycle with a lot of storage space for groceries. Also the range does no have to be
super huge with about 30-40km but I shall be extendible if needed later for some tours or the battery capacity drops.
Therefor I found the Tern GSD and the Kalkhoff durban G9 pretty appealing.
The GSD costed about 4000€ and the Durban 1200€
First I wanted to have a Tern GSD since it would more fit to me from point of driving and loadable storage.
Also the lower mass centre and the fact that I would not have to steer against the front rack are the real benefits.
However one big drawback would be the price. I could have bought nearly 3.5 times the Durban g9 for the same price as one GSD.
An other con was that this is a Bosch bike. Bosch Ebikes have for each battery one CanOpen controller inside, which
results in the fact that only Bosch batteries can be used. If you would connect a third party battery the motor drive would not support
you even though it gets power.
Also I got the information from a former working college that self replacing the 18650 cells is on some bosh batteries nearly impossible,
since they lose the configuration if power gets lost and therefore do not work with the CanOpen bus.
So instead of replacing just the 40 cells for 5€ each in case of good LG cells with 3500mAh (so 200€ total) you would have to buy the 700€
official Bosch akku.
So I boughth the Kalkhoff Durban g9 since it is much cheaper and the storage room would be enought for me at the current possion.
I would however change to the Tern GSD if I would need a bigger storage room or need Kid seats.
Then I could sell my Kalkhoff and buy a maybe used GSD much cheaper than the 4000€.
Kalkhoff durban G9
------------------
The Kalkhoff has a rear hub motor SWX02 36V 250W from the Chinese company Bafang.
The Kalkhoff is a "made in Germany" so I guess china is now part of Germany ;D.
[lightgallery
/images/blog/bafang_motor.jpg Bafang motor
lightgalleryend]
However the con of this bike system is the missing display for battery values and choosing the support levels.
With the official system only 3 steps of support are possible: 0%, 70% and 100%
Also the battery indicator is hard read since the frame pipe is blocking the view and not that bright in sunlight.
The change is done via one press on he button which is on the battery. This is not comfortable while riding.
This I wanted to improve so I disassembled the controller and battery of the durban and did take a closer look.
On the bottom connector plate there exists a bafang typical port for debugging and configuring. However this is he same interface as the
Display is using to send over a serial bus the support level.
After some research I found the pinout and connected my logic level analyser and I saw the protocol of the "display" which in this case coming from the battery.
[lightgallery
/images/blog/connector_controller.jpg Ports at the bottom of the controller;
/images/blog/connector_pinout.jpg, Bafang port pinout;
/images/blog/kalkhoff_battery_bms.jpg, Kalkhoff durban g9 - battery managment system pcb;
/images/blog/kalkhoff_battery_cells.jpg, Kalkhoff durban g9 - battery cells;
/images/blog/kalkhoff_battery_connector.jpg, Kalkhoff durban g9 - battery connector;
/images/blog/kalkhoff_battery_side.jpg, Kalkhoff durban g9 - Cell placement 3P 10S;
lightgalleryend]
Therefor I ordered a display from aliexpress which should replace the "display" within the battery.
There are several display options available. In order to save space on the handlebars I've chosen the "500C".
[lightgallery
/images/blog/bafang_500c.jpg, Bafang 500c Source: Diatone 2018 GT M3 130mm Source: www.banggood.com;
/images/blog/bafang_500c_mounted.jpg, Bafang 500c mounted on Kalkhoff Durban G9
lightgalleryend]
For connecting the 500C the 2 serial wires have to be disconnected from the controller and only the new 500c is connected to the
debug port of the controller at the bottom.
However there was one problem. The battery is including a display which auto turns off in case it could not communicate with the
controller. So after 10 min the battery turns off and the motor support is gone.
To solve this issue the Rx cable for the battery has to be plugged in. With this the battery reads the feedback of the controller but
can not transmit its own commands.
The Rx cable you can see in the pics below with a XXX isolation.
With this configuration you can choose the support level and limit by the 500c (yes also the limit :))
With this the range of the battery can be optimiced so turn off support on easy tracks and add additional support for steep hills if fully loaded.
I really wonder why Kalkhoff did no add this kind of display from the start. The only reason I could think of is to have a con or attractive selling points for
the bosch ebikes.
[lightgallery
/images/blog/kalkhoff_loaded.jpg - Kalkhoff durban g9 used for groceries and getting milk from an automat
lightgalleryend]

BIN
content/images_org/blog/Kh17_PRO_DURBAN-g9.jpg

After

Width: 7630  |  Height: 4800  |  Size: 1.6 MiB

BIN
content/images_org/blog/TN-GSD-G1-touring.jpg

After

Width: 2200  |  Height: 2200  |  Size: 1.1 MiB

BIN
content/images_org/blog/bafang_motor.jpg

After

Width: 4032  |  Height: 3024  |  Size: 3.7 MiB

BIN
content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_bms.jpg

After

Width: 3024  |  Height: 4032  |  Size: 3.5 MiB

BIN
content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_cells.jpg

After

Width: 4032  |  Height: 3024  |  Size: 3.8 MiB

BIN
content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_connector.jpg

After

Width: 4032  |  Height: 3024  |  Size: 2.9 MiB

BIN
content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_battery_side.jpg

After

Width: 4032  |  Height: 3024  |  Size: 3.0 MiB

BIN
content/images_org/blog/kalkhoff_loaded.jpg

After

Width: 4032  |  Height: 3024  |  Size: 4.4 MiB

Loading…
Cancel
Save